This summer has been so rich of learning and questioning. Some would like to simplify the issues facing education, but the more you understand the system, the more complexities reveal itself.
Last week, I was part of a group that facilitated a panel discussion at the NYC Metro Area site on current issues in education reform. Six amazing experts from different stakeholder groups joined us to share their insight – Sally Bachofer, NYSED Office of Innovative School Models; Recy Dunn, NYCDOE Charter Schools Office; Steven Thrasher, Village Voice; Evan Stone, Educators for Excellence; Susan Kriesman, Principal Manhattan Hunter Science HS; and Dr. Aaron Pallas, Professor of Sociology & Education at Teachers College.
In an effort to cover as many topics as possible, I worked with my team to create what we called a “lightening round.” We say a hot topic in public education and then the panelists respond with only: “In Favor,” “Not In Favor,” “No Opinion,” or “It’s Complicated.” Our topics ranged from school uniforms to ‘college is for everyone’ to mayoral control. As you can imagine, there were a number of diverse opinions and a lot of “it’s complicated.” I am a quotes person, so I thought I would share a few.
On Teacher Unions Role in Education Reform:
Stone: “Teacher unions are essential…”
Pallas: “They [teacher unions] haven’t really defined what exactly is good practice like most professional organizations…”
On the Role of Charter Schools in Education Reform:
Dunn: “They answer some of the supply issues around quality choice.”
Stone: “KIPP was to the public school system what FedEx was to UPS…”
On Colocation in New York City:
Thrasher: “If you are not from New York City collocation is strange….I’ve covered lots of things including the Middle East, but nothing as heated as this.”
On the Role of the NYC Chancellor:
Pallas: “Being Chancellor is an impossible job. The joke 20 years ago was anyone who wanted the job was not qualified.”
On the State of Education Going Forward:
Bachofer: “Americans are very confused about what they want schools to do. […] We need to decide what body of skills, concepts, or understanding is a diploma supposed to represent. We are not there yet.”